My experience with bfg was the sidewalls cut easy and they don't work all that well anyways. I had a set on a cj-7, and hated them. Coworker swore by them until he tried falkens on his work truck. He hasn't bought any bfg's since. He also cut 2 bfg sidewalls on rocks in a driveway.
Tried the Toyo at3 on my old 2000 crew cab long box 3500. They hooked up well, wasn't happy with the amount of tread squirm. Just felt loose on the highway.
Work truck has a service body, 18 crew cab long box Duramax that weighs about 6k rear, 5k front. Falken wildpeak at3w on there currently. They work well but do throw rocks like crazy. The falkens work better than the Toyo at2, and the hankook at2. The hankooks we're scary on ice, and I blew sidewalls out of them every 25-30k for the 3 sets I tried (shop warrantied, I gave up after the 3rd set).
My daily is a 16 crew cab long box 2500 Chevy. I run Michelin at2 in the summer because they work fine for everything and last forever.
General grabber Arctic LT in the winter with studs. Holy **** are they on another level. I can cruise right through stuff in 2wd that would have me clenching the seat with my ass in 4wd with the Michelins.
The single biggest thing is that I can actually stop. The shiny hard pack or ice that has any normal tires turn into a slow motion wreck, I can still jam on the brakes and slam into the seat belt.