I have owned a 2012 pro, 2014 cat, 2014 xm and 2 weeks ago took a 2015 cat 4 stroke turbo out for a day.
The turbo cat was a tank! no good at all for sidehilling or boondocking way too heavy.
The pro and the doo are the lightest feeling sleds,steering wise.
The cat 800 has heavy steering and feels more planted in the front end. great for the trails in and out of the mountains. tried a few different sets of skis and different suspension settings and it didnt lighten up the heavy steering feeling. Just feels bigger and heavier even tho its a few pds lighter on the scales than the doo.
The pro is hands down the easiest to sidehill and boondock, will stay on one ski all day long without being fussy. It is light no doubt about that. The only downfall is the reliability of the motor. build quality is not on par with the doo, neither is the cat.
The doo is by far the best built sled....quality wise. The warranty is the best and the fuel and oil usage is much better than the others. The etec pulls hard also. The sled works much better than I originally thought. I didnt give it much chance the first time I rode one (about 20min). It is a different sled to ride for sure but when you get used to it its pretty darn good.
Cat uses the most fuel and oil of the 3. It does pull pretty strong but with the 2014 gearing it tops out quickly and doesnt really have any top end. The doo will outpull the cat because of this gearing.
The cat does hold less snow on the back now that it doesnt have the rear heat exchanger but overheats on the trail alot faster now.
Overall I decided to keep the xm because of how much better the quality of everything is, light steering, fuel and oil usage, better warranty, great power and still pretty reliable. It suprised me the most of what to expect after coming off the cat and pro. All sleds have their weaknesses and strong points and for myself the doo seems to be the best of both worlds....light feeling like the pro but more reliable.....pulls strong like the cat but feels alot lighter.......and better WARRANTY AND FUEL MILEAGE than both of them by far!!!
JMHO!!!